OCD-afflicted Griffin has only lost his 1st love, Theo, in a drowning accident. In an attempt to store every piece of the past, he forges a a friendly relationship with Theo’s last sweetheart, Jackson. When Jackson starts to exhibit signs of guilt, Griffin suspects he’s hiding something, and can stop at nothing at all to get to the truth about Theo’s death. But as the grieving set grows closer, visitors will question Griffin’s own edition from the truth-both with regards to what he’s ready to conceal and what true love means.