With regards to her heart, Arabella D’Angelo has moved on-even though she still lives in Mirror Lake, Connecticut, just a little tourist town with a long memory for mistakes. Ever the dutiful girl of the cantankerous widower who keeps grudges, Bella provides spent the past twelve years raising her younger sibling and making a name for herself as a successful psychologist. Today, when she isn’t guidance a lonely-hearts membership for senior women, she’s humoring her matchmaking girlfriends. Bella resists the about Can’t Stop Caring You romancing of their blind dates, yet her close friends hope she’ll fall for an area and scrap plans for a fresh start in Chicago. After that, right before Bella’s thirtieth birthday, her 1st love, Roman Spikonos, results to Reflection Lake. When he movements nearby to her family’s garden-center business to run his grandparents’ orchard, it stirs up gossip-and a tempest of passions-just in time for pumpkin harvest. As Roman and Bella once more get swept up inside a swirl of desire and heartache, not forgetting her overprotective father’s fury, Mirror Lake will quickly find out if the Italian hometown beauty and her memorable Greek god can stand a second chance.